Tuesday, February 20, 2007

Urban condo market analysis: noise or signal?

Here are two sets of urban condo data from highly reliable sources and that on the surface are difficult to reconcile:

1. The Warren Group "Boston" (defined as Beacon Hill, Back Bay, North End, and South End) condo median price for January over the last three years (available here):
2005 - $502,000
2006 - $364,000
2007 - $580,000
That works out to a yoy decline of 27.5% from 2005 to 2006, and a 59.3% increase from 2006 to 2007. Does anyone believe that the median condo in these neighborhoods increased in price 59% from last January to this January? An obvious problem here is the sample size. The total Jan. condo sales for each year were:
2005 - 172
2006 - 112
2007 - 143
If a new project or two comes online during a particular month, it can have an inordinate effect on the median price reported. To me these data are useless without more info about the projects that were coming online, and/or more data about the size and type of units that were selling.

2. Joe Wolvek of Coldwell Banker Residential Brokerage reports on his website (here) the price per square foot (obtained from MLS-PIN) for three of the four neighborhoods lumped together in the Warren Group "Boston" sample. Plotted below are the data for the past 3.5 years, plus the data for closed sales this year through 2/7:





Price per sq ft appears to have peaked in late 2005 / early 2006 for all three neighborhoods. A simple analysis of the quarterly YOY change in price per square foot results in the following plot:

The light blue line represents the MA statewide change in median condo price (not normalized to square footage). I added this line to show how closely these urban condo markets are tracking statewide trends when price per square foot is analyzed.

In contrast to the Warren Group numbers, there does not appear to be a significant surge upward in price per square foot in these neighborhoods. All three show price per square foot down 2-10% YOY so far in Q1 2007. Perhaps the North End is the critical piece of missing info that would reconcile the Warren and Wolvek numbers. Perhaps not. More likely the Warren numbers for nieghborhoods undergoing rapid development (at ever increasing price points) are subject to inevitable noise and sampling problems.

24 comments:

Unknown said...

Hi Mass Housing, please consider linking to my site: www.HousingDerivatives.typepad.com. Not only do we link to you for Boston cash market data, Boston is a CME housing futures city and is an important component in the housing derivatives world. Thank you for your consideration.

notsofastlouie said...

You focus exclusively on prices, which I agree decreased especially last summer.

But what about the number of sales? You'll find, if you do the analysis, that sales increased significantly over the last few months in the urban condo market (as a whole), and that there has been a discrepancy between urban condo sales and state-wide overall home sales.

Unknown said...

Massachusetts has been a significant state in American history. Plymouth, Massachusetts, was the second permanent English settlement in North America. Colonists from England founded many towns and villages in the present-day territory of Massachusetts very early in the nation's history in the 1620s and 1630s. The Boston area became known as the, sportsbook, "Cradle of Liberty" for the ferment there which led to the American Revolution and the independence of the United States from Great Britain. Massachusetts was the first U.S. state to abolish slavery and was a center of the temperance movement and abolitionist activity in the years leading to the American Civil War. The state has contributed many prominent politicians to national service, including the Kennedy family. http://www.enterbet.com

Costa Rica car rentals said...

Campeche Beach and Resort, visit us new Beachfront Condo and Mexico Golf Course and Marina.

You can find more info at: http://www.costarica4retirement.com/Mexico-CampecheBeach/index.html

lisa_d said...

This article is a must read. Thanks for the updates. Reading along your blog. Keep on posting.

Deirdre G
philippine real estate

kimberly sayer said...

Know how important timely and reliable real estate data and financial information is to your business. With more than 135 years of experience collecting and publishing real estate-focused news and public records, it's no wonder that most real estate and lending professionals, marketers, home buyers and sellers rely on our products to keep track of the New England market whether they are local or national businesses.Our products and services enable our customers to see the entire assessor record of a property, view deeds,costa rica fishinglocation maps, find comparable sales, build marketing lists consisting of targeted prospects, find pre-foreclosure records, determine property value or profile an entire community, as well as stay on top of the latest news & events affecting their industries. Our News publications help you stay abreast of the New England Real Estate market, and our custom publishing program will help you position your organization as an industry leader.
http://www.fishingcostaricaexperts.com

lisa_d said...

I can see that you are putting a lot of time and effort into your blog and detailed articles! I am deeply in love with every single piece of information you post here. Will be back often to read more updates!

Deirdre G
condo in Philippines

Unknown said...

The information and the graphics are very interesting and useful. Have you something about lots in costa rica, I am very interested.

Anonymous said...

There are many opportunities for a prospective individual or couple to get into the real estate market.Costa rica toursWhether you are looking for a permanent residence or a real estate investment home, both the United States and Canada markets provide numerous types of housing that will suit your lifestyle and requirements.
http://www.kingtours.com

paula said...

Great blog- this looks very professional and tips very clean. Good luck rolling it out!

Paula M
philippine real estate

Real Estate Philippines said...

Thanks a lot for this valuable information.

new houses for sale Philippines

bronsonespinosa said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
bronsonespinosa said...

very interesting stats you got there! nice post!

-Philippine Condos

Real Estate Philippines said...

Nicely explained. It's indeed an art to stop new visitors with your attractive writing style.


houses for sale Philippines

my real estate blog said...

Great analysis! I enjoyed reading it and I am really like to read interesting post like this. Thanks for sharing.


condo in Philippines

HACKER said...

You focus exclusively on prices, which I agree decreased especially last summer.
Zafir Seba yıldızesmer sinemalarından çıplakshanerini izleme

Yeni İş Fikirleri said...

hii blogs post cameles
Zerrin Egeliler turkyıldızın arşivlerinden seçelmelre vard

I Love real estate blogs said...

So far, I managed to go though only some of posts you discuss here, but I find them very interesting and informative. Just want say thank you for the information you have shared. Regards


condominium makati

Ray Brickman said...

In the end of the latter, as the world economy dives down, prices per sq ft for homes for sale will also drop. Thus, having higher supply and lower demand.

As of now, condo for rent in the Philippines is at its peak. :)

Ray Brickman
Real Estate Broker in the Philippines

samanthadoors said...

One of the best property in Costa Rica, Indeed a great place.

philippine real estate

plumberAU said...

People dream of owning the home of their dreams. When the time comes that you are financially capable of buying your own house, you might want to consider opting for one of the finest condominiums for sale in the market.

Condo Market

Unknown said...

I have read a few of the articles on your website now, and I really like your style of blogging. I added it to my favorite’s blog site list and will be checking back soon…
The Nautical Condos

Anonymous said...

It’s an informative post. You showed some amazing stats about prices of condo per square feet. I want to buy a
condo in Toronto
so I want to analyze the prices of different condos here.

Video Teraveloka said...

Kesempurnaan yang selalu dicari didunia ini termasuk juga ketika bermain judi online 2019 maupun offline. Namun ketika kesempurnaan yang ingin didapatkan justru malah di salah artikan oleh orang orang tidak paham makna dari Poneros yaitu Kejahatan (Baca Selengkapnya...)